Matilda Fraser—recipient of the Blue Oyster Art Project Space Summer Writing Residency in 2015—spent six weeks in Ōtepoti Dunedin developing a collection of essays in response to the question “is criticism still relevant?”
Aquinas College, Dunedin, 2015.Against Efficiency and other texts expands, rethinks, and inverts this question, examining the value-exchange systems surrounding present modes of critique, while posing new questions around how we address art, even if it doesn’t always address us.
Matilda’s suite of texts is the first collection of essays to be published by The Lumière Reader. As a Residency partner, The Lumière Reader provided publishing support alongside mentorship from Founding Editor Tim Wong and Blue Oyster director Chloe Geoghegan.
For the Blue Oyster, it is the inaugural special edition of a new biannual Online Publications initiative thanks to the renewed support of the programme from Creative New Zealand.
A huge thank you to those who supported the Residency:
- Steve and Morag from Aquinas College, for their interest and investment in the Residency;
- our selection panel, which consisted of the Blue Oyster Arts Trustees as well as Thomasin Sleigh and Lynley Edmeades;
- Gregory Kan;
- the other high-quality applicants who took the time to apply;
- and everyone who donated to the Residency Givealittle Cause.

About the publication
Alongside the creation of a satellite website to host Against Efficiency and other texts in 2015, The Lumière Reader produced a limited edition chapbook of the essay collection. Designed by Tim Wong, 80 copies were printed. As part of this new archival site, you can view or download a digital copy of the chapbook online (PDF).
About the Summer Writing Residency
Motivated to promote diverse perspectives and healthy debate around arts culture in Aotearoa, Against Efficiency and other texts is the result of a collaboration between the Blue Oyster Art Project Space and The Lumière Reader. Both organisations recognised a shared opportunity to foster creative and critically engaged writing practices around contemporary art by offering the recipient an opportunity to use the Blue Oyster as a studio for six weeks, and then develop a publication with mentorship from The Lumière Reader.
Residency applicants were invited to respond to the question “is criticism still relevant?” and the premise of the Residency was to develop an extended text within the field of contemporary art criticism.
Matilda Fraser, Whanganui, 2015.About the Residency recipient
Matilda Fraser is a Te Whanganui-a-Tara Wellington-based artist and writer who holds a Bachelor of Fine Arts with Honours from Massey University (2012). She has exhibited her work at Enjoy Public Art Gallery (2013) and has written for EyeContact as well as a range of publications for exhibition. She has also studied at the International Institute of Modern Letters.